From NEWSDAY December 31, 2005
King willing
to redo bill
Outcry over measure to tighten border leads him to say he'd rewrite parts
seen as threat to LI church members
BY BART JONES
STAFF WRITER
After an outpouring of criticism from churches and relief groups, Rep. Peter King
(R-Seaford) said Friday he is willing to reword the legislation he co-sponsored
that would have made it illegal to assist undocumented immigrants.
The bill calls for building a 698-mile fence along the U.S.-Mexico border, turning
undocumented immigrants into felons and permitting "deputization" of
local and state police officers as immigration agents. But it also included a
provision that makes it a crime for anyone to assist undocumented immigrants to
"come or remain" in the United States. Officials from churches and relief
agencies and immigrant advocates said this could lead to the imprisonment of priests,
nuns, social workers, doctors and Good Samaritans who may provide these immigrants
with anything from counseling to a ride to the grocery store.
King said that was never the intention of the provision, which he said targets
gangs that smuggle undocumented immigrants into the country. The measure "is
not aimed at humanitarian groups at all," said King, who is chairman of the
House Homeland Security Committee. "If there are any specific words they
want changed, I can assure you that will be done."
King said the groups were misinterpreting the bill and that "the church is
developing a persecution complex here ... If an alien smuggling ring gets a guy
into the country and he stops at St. Brigid's at a soup kitchen, we're not going
to lock up the pastor of St. Brigid's. They're not part of the smuggling ring."
Some church workers greeted King's words with relief Friday, although they said
they were still outraged by the bill in general and do not believe they were misinterpreting
its broad language. "If we can discuss it, excellent," Yanira Chacon,
a church outreach worker at St. Brigid's in Westbury, said in Spanish. "The
ideal for me is that this bill doesn't pass at all."
Church and immigrant groups call the bill the harshest piece of anti-immigrant
legislation in 70 years. Supporters say it would help bring under control a situation
of anarchy at the border that has swelled the number of undocumented immigrants
in the country to 11 million, including an estimated 100,000 on Long Island.
King said the bill is unlikely to be passed in its present form by the Senate,
which he expected to add provisions for a guest-worker program granting temporary
visas mainly to low-skilled workers. However, he did say "a significant portion
of it has to become law otherwise no immigration reform bill will pass the House."
Staff writer J. Jioni Palmer contributed to this story.
Copyright (c) 2005, Newsday, Inc.